76 Comments
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Would anyone else be into swimsuit recs?

Expand full comment
author

we'll get on this!

Expand full comment

Please make sure to include plus size options!! :)

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

I have that Kate Baer poem framed in my hallway--it was a post-separation gift for myself. Every time I walk past it I'm reminded of the big juicy life I'm creating for myself!

Expand full comment
author

Omg I LOVE that, Lee. So beautiful. I'm going to share this with Kate, I'm sure she'll be so touched.

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard, Kaitlyn Teer

playing a Soul Train compilation while hosting — genius!

Expand full comment
author

see you soon, hunter!!

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Thank you for this staggeringly excellent list! When I saw my beloved —“the dip”—I thought, this list looks promising. And as I continued to read/click through, it sure delivered! Almost too much goodness to take in at once. :)

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

How fast did I order those painters pants...love this!

Expand full comment

I bookmarked them SO fast!

Expand full comment
Apr 20Liked by Joanna Goddard

Oh my gosh - my comment made it! The dip! It really is the BEST! My day/weekend/week have been made 😍

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Ok, the adorable signet ring made me think... wtf am I going to get my daughter for her 18th birthday (early may) and then HS graduation (early june)? i feel like both merit Serious, Meaningful gifts and am currently stumped. I have a "everyone watches women's sports" tee coming for her birthday and... that's it. I could use other ideas, if any comments readers have them!

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

My go-to graduation gift is a tool set -- it says "you're a grown up" and is so useful in a new apartment or dorm room for hanging and fixing random things (tape measure, level, hammer, wrench, pliers...). If one celebration merits a ring (beautiful, feminine, delightful for its uselessness), then the other day gets the tools (practical, strong, independent).

Expand full comment

My mother's best friend gave me a tool set for my high school graduation gift. I am 41 and have proudly taken out that tool set every time we need just the right tool, and thanked Jane in my mind for reminding me that I know how to take care of sh*t, even if I didn't know that for a while.

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

and a jumper battery for the car if she has one.

Expand full comment

You are an actual genius. (Or maybe I am the genius for posing this question here 😂) I think between jewelry, digital frame and badass toolbox, I can totally pull off these gifts. THANK YOU!!

Expand full comment

YOU’RE the genius :)

Expand full comment

I won an “ergonomic tool set for women” as a door prize at our high school graduation lock in, 20 years ago (🤯), and I still use it all the time. It came in a lightweight case and has all of the essentials.

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Catbird or Gldn jewerly are great for celebrating milestones. So pretty and special! I'm a scientist and I buy myself a new solid gold charm or earrings ($100-200) when I publish a new research article that I'm particularly proud of (maybe once every 2 years or so), and something more splurgy for major milestones (something similar to these https://www.catbirdnyc.com/gemma-garnet-earrings-pair.html when I got my first faculty position).

Expand full comment

Co-signing both of these! My husband designed my (non-traditional) engagement ring with Catbird and I love it so much, and when our son was born a few years later he got me the small disc birth flower necklace from GLDN which I also love so much (and can’t wait to add another when our next baby is born in the fall!)

Expand full comment

I just bought myself a tiny catbird z for the initial of a beloved cousin on the anniversary of his passing. Was like a little hug for myself. ❤️

Expand full comment
founding

My mom got me a birthstone ring when I got my first period. I'm thinking an initial signet would be a timeless piece for my nearly 12 year old when she reaches that milestone.

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

what an exciting time for your daughter! this may sound boring (and isn’t an object), but the best gift my mom ever gave me as i transitioned into adulthood was helping me start a retirement account that has grown into a gift im so grateful for with each passing year as i get older 💛

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Grace, I am so boring that I beat you to that - I started one for her last year!

Expand full comment
author

love this!

Expand full comment
author

I love that tee idea :) for other gifts, what kinds of things is your daughter into? is she leaving after graduation or staying home/nearby? I love those photo frames that you can digitally rotate photos through -- I'm blanking on what they are called but one of those might be cool if she's moving out of town. I also love the idea of a signet ring or a passed down piece of jewelry, if you have one that you think she'd love. xoxo

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Oh, a digital photo frame is a great idea for graduation! We are in Maine and she's going to North Carolina, so I think she'll like seeing dog and family photos. She's into sports (majoring in sports management), her job at a beloved local bakery, and her very awesome girlfriend. She has worked through a whole lot of crap over the last several years - her dad (my ex-husband) died unexpectedly in 2017, the pandemic really put a damper on her early HS years, she dealt with an eating disorder... all of that has taken up a ton of space in her life and she is really looking forward to independence, warmer weather and the chance to really focus on topics she cares about.

Expand full comment
author

She sounds wonderful, Michaela! And clearly you adore her :)

Expand full comment

Omg please do a story on tees! I am googling that women’s sports one and adding to cart now (even though I do not in fact watch any sports but IF I DID they would be women’s sports!). Thank you Michaela!

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Everyone watches women’s sports!! I need this tee

Expand full comment
founding

Luggage

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Book editor at real simple mag sounds like a dream job!!

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Obsessed with the airport sign thing!!

Expand full comment

That was me! So weird to open Big Salad and see myself inside it, but that’s me and my sister at Dublin airport 💕

Expand full comment

I just flew home to Dublin today and noticed all those people waiting expectantly in the arrivals area! Such a lovely idea!

Expand full comment
author

me too. so sweet.

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Can’t wait to try the Alison Roman dip. Love her recipes! About to make her chocolate cookies for my kids birthday!

Expand full comment
author

omg those shortbread cookies are GOOD

Expand full comment
Apr 20Liked by Joanna Goddard

Of course this list was excellent! Thank you!

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

Speaking of pants…I am always on the lookout for pants that look real but are comfy around the waist, if you get my meaning.

Expand full comment
founding
Apr 20Liked by Joanna Goddard

Hate to say it but the answer is spanx!!! So comfy but also feel put together!

Expand full comment
Apr 20Liked by Joanna Goddard

Respectfully, I think you are going in the wrong direction. Shapeware and jeans that can be described rigid are the opposite. More like an elasticized or flexible waste on something that looks like pants.

Expand full comment
Apr 20Liked by Joanna Goddard

I think Cate may be referring to some of Spanx’s newer pant product? I don’t own any, but their kick flare perfect pant is very popular amongst my colleagues! No button or zip - just pull on.

Expand full comment

OMG thank you for pointing out the TJ candle dupe!

Expand full comment
Apr 19Liked by Joanna Goddard

would agree with the East Fork mug - I have it and it is lovely addition to morning coffee :)

Expand full comment

A couple of years ago, I ordered 2 east fork mugs on sale and since then, my husband and I have ordered 4 more (usually in their “seconds” section) and basically eliminated all other mugs. They are THAT good. Definitely one of my favorite every day items!

Expand full comment

totally! i reach for it over all other mugs. worth it!!!

Expand full comment

I love White Sands National Park! It’s so beautiful! And I am obsessed with the Trader Joe’s candles!

Expand full comment
Apr 20Liked by Joanna Goddard

Ok a cygnet/signet ring has to be the most clever product name in recent history. I love how delicate it is - if I were to buy one to commemorate a relationship, whose initial would I use? Theirs? Mine? Common last name?

Expand full comment